"I never intended any comparisons with any other creature."

Fair enough, but context is important and you can't separate the human eye from all the other eyes . . . even if you want to single the human eye out it's unreasonable as according to you god created every eye that's ever seen, so he's inviting comparison.


"the idea that the eye is wired backward comes from a lack of knowledge of eye function and anatomy"

Eek! This comment starts from the assumption the eye is designed, which it isn't as it evolved. It's not wired backward or forward (?), but is what it is. The point is that were you to design an eye you could make a better job of it, and this fact argues against it having been designed in the first place (unless god was having an off-day during the eyes bit).


"now that don't sound like rubbish design to me."

Thats cos it ain't design.