The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #152971   Message #3580696
Posted By: GUEST,Allan Conn
02-Dec-13 - 10:21 AM
Thread Name: Performances: Why do they all sound the same?
Subject: RE: Why do they all sound the same?
We're maybe just going to have to agree to disagree here. I just don't agree with the idea that people look on covers with disdain. Locally virtually all the singer-songwriters I know also do covers anway. Some of the guest artists we've had in recent years have done only their own songs (ie Kieran Halpin, Jackie Leven)but most throw in the odd cover or trad song too - and those who I've mentioned had a strong enough repetoire to justify themselves only doing their own songs anyway.

I don't agree that those songwriters who sing their own songs all sound the same whilst those who write for other people don't. Those of both persuasions can be just as prone to formulaic writing or following trends.

I'm just a hobbyist so don't actively trade my wares. I do it because I love doing it. Though yes it'd be great for someone to record one of my songs. I'd love that but it doesn't stop me singing them myself too. In fact it is the easiest way to let other artists hear them. We had a Frank Rae visit our open mic recently who liked one of my songs and asked if I minded if his group 'Rudeigin' played it. Not a huge deal as they are not a big name or anything but I was really pleased he liked it and wanted to play it. He describes himself as a singer songwriter but he's still open to playing someone else's song and had I not sung at the open mic I doubt if he'd ever have heard it by any other means.