I pasted the first paragraph of the article thinking that anyone interested might read the second, and maybe more. But you obviously didn't. "But he stayed his ruling pending an appeal by the Obama administration, which argued in court in defense of the program."

You National Socialists are a piece of work. NSA spying violates the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. constitution. You don't have to be a law professor to know that. You should be ashamed to argue in favor of violating the constitution. If you ever took an oath to it, then what you're doing here makes you a traitor.