The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #70273 Message #3586057
Posted By: Phil Edwards
23-Dec-13 - 12:55 PM
Thread Name: Lyr Req: Bright Morning Stars/Bright Morning Star
Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Bright Morning Stars/Bright Morning Star
I got into an argument about this just the other day - I've sung (or led) it a few times, always as
"Bright morning star's a-rising"
which of course sounds pretty much the same as
"Bright morning stars a-rising".
Anyway, I was accused of singing about bright morning stars, plural. I explained about the "star's", apostrophe S, and said that I'd got it from the Young Tradition recording (which I'm lucky enough to have). My friend was having none of it & maintained that the YT sang it as
"Bright morning star a-rising"
no stars plural and no star's apostrophe S.
I've just listened to it again, and I'm sure there's an S in there - in fact they linger on the "a-" so long it sounds more like
"Bright morning stars are rising"
which would be wrong in a whole other way. (Unless you prefer the Stanley Brothers' take on it to Martin Carthy's, of course.)
What do other people think? Should it be
"Bright morning star a-rising"?
And what were the Young Tradition singing?