"You can discuss whatever you like but the fact remains, I have produced numerous quotes from many historians contradicting your version of history"
Used to be all modern historians - good soldiers never give ground
You've actually produced a tiny minority and ignored the general views - "general - not General - you'd never contradict an officer now, would you)
"You can discuss whatever you like "
That's damned big of you.
It appears that soldiers having a right to expect the promises they were given before they were sent to be slaughtered and our right to discuss the fulfillment of those promises is an alien concept to you.
As you were - and will always be private.
Pip-pip
Jim Caroll