The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #133984   Message #3590290
Posted By: Jim Carroll
09-Jan-14 - 04:02 AM
Thread Name: BS: Christmas Truce (1914)
Subject: RE: BS: Christmas Truce (1914)
"Jim, you have just lied to us all."
No Keith - you put up what Sheffield said, I pointed out what he said, both about the need to change current historical assessment of WW1 and of his describing the War and being an Imperialist one - he chose to blame German Imperialism for the war, putting out on a limb from all the historians, who have that suggested that this is both incorrect and unproductive.
You won't discuss his false premise, that the war has been regarded as "trivial" when it hasn't, Yyou won't discuss the treatment of the soldiers who were betrayed by the British Government on their return, you won't discuss your lying here and anywhere else.
You are now trying to implicate me accuse me of what you now routinely do on this forum - lie to score points.
The fact that you have not responded in any way to my list of your having lied seem, in my view, that you are unable to and are forced to accept them.
If you wish to continue talking about lying I'll be happy to complete that list and fill in the details with cut-'n-pastes from other threads - whatdya think - are you up for it?
Don't you dare try to drag me or anybody down to your sewer level behaviour
Yours in gratitude for vainly attempting to cast your "pearls of wisdom" before us "swine"
Jim Carroll