The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #133984   Message #3599833
Posted By: Jim Carroll
09-Feb-14 - 02:41 PM
Thread Name: BS: Christmas Truce (1914)
Subject: RE: BS: Christmas Truce (1914)
"My views are those of the historians, "
No it isn't - your tiny band of historians are not a consensus - you have presented them as if they are.
Even if they were, they would by a minute number of dissenting historians among a large number of experts researching the war
Your case has been entirely based on your historians - you have no arguments other thean the cut-'n-pastes you have carefully selected - you have cooked the books - you have no case
But this will in no way stop you hiding behind them, just as the TV documentaries will stop you from claiming that they back up your case when they say the opposite
You are a fanatical nutter who tells lies to back up your fanaticism.
Even your last answers are evasive;
"Not by the government."
Nobdy has said by the Government - by the Government controlled press and the officers doesn't make any difference to the Tommies who were slaghtered who lied to them, they were still dead.
You're sussed
Jim Carroll