A few songs that I haven't seen mentioned that I like are
- A Stable Lamp is Lighted (Richard Wilbur, © 1961) to the tune ANDÚJAR (David Hurd, © 1984); there's another, earlier (© 1969) tune called TOLLEFSON (after the composer) in the Lutheran Book of Worship, but I haven't tried it yet.
- One Candle Is Lit by Mary Anne Parrott, © 1995 Chalice Press (in the Chalice Hymnal), set to CRADLE SONG, the Kirkpatrick tune often used for Away in a Manger; this should be quite effective as a sort of antiphon to the weekly lighting of Advent candles
- Child in the Manger to BUNESSAN ("Morning has broken")
- On this day earth shall ring ("Personent hodie")
- In Dulci Jubilo (macaronic with Latin the way Suso sang it, not the Neale chauvinizing version or its revisionist revisions)
A few that are in my Esperanto hymnal (see Christmas list) but that I am looking for English versions of (if you know the English texts, send me PM or email!) are:
Liland
- At even, long ago, by C. Bingham (also titled "The Star Eternal")
- Che l' Kristofesto ghojas ni, by Ellen Gregory
- Det susar genom livets strid, by Carl Boberg (famous in English for How Great Thou Art, but none of his other Swedish hymns seem to have been translated - into English, that is; we have several in Esperanto)
- Fra fjord og fjære, by Magnus Brostrup Landstad
- La Saghuloj pro Advento, by Leonard Ivor Gentle
- Min själ berömmer Gud med fröjd, another one by Boberg (this time his Magnificat)
- Mit Hjerte altid vanker, by Hans Adolph Brorson
- My heart and voice I raise, by Benjamin Rhodes
- No koma Guds englar, by Elias Blix
- Sæle jolekveld, by Elias Blix (to the tune usually associated with Jesu, geh voran)