Musket
Quite a few instances on this thread of people saying something is because they say it is.

There is certainly one that I can think of. ("It's true. It's true. It's true I tell you.")

If over 50% of us were actual not boutique Christians, as in actually believing impossible claims etc, would that make the rational ones amongst us weird by consensus?

No, but we would be REGARDED as weird and, quite possibly, dangerous.