The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #153834 Message #3605676
Posted By: Jim Carroll
28-Feb-14 - 02:42 AM
Thread Name: Lyr Req: Ideas for more folk songs for me to try?
Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Ideas for more folk songs for me to try?
"I would suggest that you decide whether you want (mostly) to sing English, Scottish, Irish, or American." Sorry Richard - crossed lines. That is my point exactly - sing what you want but do so in your own voice, not anybody else's. To me, wanting to sing like anybody but yourself is pointless - why try to sound like Shirley Collins say, when Shirley makes a far better job of sounding like herself, so you might as well go and buy her albums. The joy of singing is interpreting a song for yourself and making that song work for you - making it part of you. You can only do that in your own voice, otherwise you become little more than one of those sad pub 'tribute' artists. I don't believe you can do that using somebody else's voice or accent. 'm not suggesting for a minute that you can't adapt what other singers have to offer to your own singing, but that's a mile away from trying to sound like them But there you go - that's me (nobody else)! Jim Carroll