The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #150911   Message #3614479
Posted By: Jim Carroll
02-Apr-14 - 05:39 AM
Thread Name: BS: Irish Potato Blight- Cause found
Subject: RE: BS: Irish Potato Blight- Cause found
Your consistent claim of majority historians is based on a quote from Kinealy - that is the sole basis for your claim
"It was Kinealy who stated that they are a majority."
Kinealy said that the majority of historians have avoided the causes and the culprits of the Famine, not that they don't blame Britain - she herself blames Britain's refusal to act to assist Ireland, as does every other historian you have quoted - she goes further to say that what Britain did do was exactly the opposite of assisting - you have the quote of her making this statement.
Your case of "majority" is based on your having deliberately twisted the writings of a historian who is saying exactly the opposite.
If you can show that she is claiming that the majority "don't blame Britain" - please produce it.
If you can show that any historian has made such a claim - please produce it.
I am producing documented facts based on documentation contemporary to the Famine, so far from half a dozen hsirtorians (plenty more to come) - if you can show that it is not true, invented, made up, revisionist - whatever nonsense you choose to hise behine, please produce it - otherwise, go away as you promised and don't make yourself more of a lying idiot than you have so far.
Now - MAJORITY HISTORIANS PLEASE should be fairly simple.
Jim Carroll