The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #154376 Message #3622613
Posted By: Dave the Gnome
27-Apr-14 - 04:01 PM
Thread Name: BS: Islamic radicalism . . .
Subject: RE: BS: Islamic radicalism . . .
Jim, you have just said, amongst other things,
I indicted those who watched it happen without doing anything about it
and
I don't blame the people of Lewes
But your post on the thread concerned was
it isn't too long ago that the good people of Lewes were burning a caravan full of 'Pikeys' at their annual bonfire festival.
It is there for you to refresh your memory if you like. Re: 'Bacup Nuters and Racism' From: Jim Carroll Date: 24 Apr 14 - 04:03 AM.
Now, nowhere in that statement do you only indict the people who watched it happen and did nothing. You did indict 'the good people of Lewes' as a whole.
I fully understand if it was a mistake to tar those good people with the same brush and, if so, you should say what you said is not what you meant. The statement you made was a typical Daily Mail style headline. You cannot say, on the one hand, that we can only blame the extremists, which I fully agree with, and then go on to say 'the good people of Lewes were burning a caravan full of pikeys.'
I am not trying to argue just for the sake of it here either. I am just saying that you cannot say one thing and do another without people picking up on it.
Cheers
DtG