The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #150703   Message #3637424
Posted By: John on the Sunset Coast
28-Jun-14 - 05:11 PM
Thread Name: BS: Small hope for Israel/Palestine
Subject: RE: BS: Small hope for Israel/Palestine
"John, are you by innuendo attributing "anti-Semitic language and arguments" to me? If so, please identify same."

I do stand by my statement in context. You wrote that, in essence, bobad is quick to play the A-card. I was responding specically to that statement of yours. During the fifteen years I have been at Mudcat, I have read posts which can be said to be anti-Semitic based on agreed international definitions. Some of those folks no longer post here, some still do. I am not the arbiter of what is anti-Semitic; I posted a link to the international definitions for everybody here to read if they care to. For all I know only bobad and I have read them, or maybe everybody has read and understood them.

The bottom line is this: if one uses the consensus identified anti-Semitic language/arguments more than seldom, maybe that one needs to become more self-aware, if they consider themselves to be fair critics. I believe that my statement @12:41 accurately reflects that.

Greg, last night I did all the research for you that I'm going to do. It is my job neither to look for damning posts from you, nor to determine that you have never so argued. Only you know truly know what you mean when you post. That goes for all of us on Mudcat.

JotSC