Steve, it is a fact that they fight from civilian areas so that retaliation kills civilians, so they use human shields.

Jim, she describes battle around the area of the hospital and treating the wounded.
In her original account she says there was no sound in the camp under the flares.
In either account, nothing she says contradicts Israel's version of events.

"Miss Siegel and another female nurse from Holland . The rest were lined up against the wall and executed. Miss Siegel was among 3 Americans who testified in the Kahane Commission, the Israeli official inquiry into the massacre.
Noam Chomski"

That was not rue according to both accounts.