and what has any of that to do with what AJP Taylor said about the calibre of officers and leaders from Haig downwards and how WW2 officers learned from their experiences under bad senior leaders?

Nothing.

Who has revised that?

No one.

Back to Terribulus scribbling guest. (Oh, and leave the political voting pattern and friendships of real historians out of it. Keith has tried that trick and got caught with his trousers down, and everybody laughed at his arse.)