The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #156062   Message #3684372
Posted By: Jim Carroll
10-Dec-14 - 01:40 PM
Thread Name: Oh! What a Lovely War! - BBC Radio 2
Subject: RE: Oh! What a Lovely War! - BBC Radio 2
"I am not just throwing up names, I am quoting named historians."
No you are not - you are claiming their support for your views,
"No you can't."
Yu have been given dozens by those who go in for that sort of thing - you have rejected them as "leftie" or "Trotskyst" or "out of date" or "revisionist" or "anonymous"
You were given a list of over a hundred historians who are all working on different aspects of history and all coming to different conclusions - you stated that you would not even look at it because there were too many
It has been pointed out that your six have said themselves that they are in the minority, yet you still claim they prove your case.
You were given a list of points made by historians o the Paxman series (some of them on your own list) all contradicting your claims - you refuse to even acknowledge those points
You are a moron
Jim Carroll