Keith, All through your comments here you have stated that all modern Historians support the case that Haig was a superb General and that all previous Historians were either left wing, subversive, has their own axe to grind etc etc.

The historian YOU quoted (05.50) said that Haig made mistakes, big mistakes.

So we have a situation that clearly contradicts your previous stance that ALL modern Historians back Haig. No they don't and Thanks to you we have the written evidence that they don't.

I wouldn't want you as my defence lawyer!