The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #156239   Message #3688100
Posted By: Keith A of Hertford
23-Dec-14 - 12:04 PM
Thread Name: BS: I am not an historian but........
Subject: RE: BS: I am not an historian but........
As long as I have been on this form you have filled this forum with your racist and sectarian filth

Lies. resorting to personal attack and lying smears.. You might as well admit you have lost.

"Neil Faulkner in a bookshop"
Amazon!
They sell anything and everything.
How about a real bookshop?
How about a library?

No they don't - you have been given examples of where they contradict what you

Not true.
Not one single proper living historian.
You can not name one!

No single historian has ever confirmed all of your three points - not one -
Margaret Macmillan to name just one.

Not all historians have written about all three.
No living historian has contradicted any of my claims, except extreme Thatcherite Ferguson who only does one.

THERE IS NO SINGLE VIEW ON THE HISTORY OF WORLD WAR ONE, AS ALL YOUR OWN HISTORIANS HAVE STATED

True, but on my 3 points they all agree.

- YOU ARE MAKING IT UP

I don't need to. They really do say what I say because I learned it from them.

Why, last week I looked at one and found that you were trying to mislead us.

Not true Steve.
I am scrupulously accurate with all my quotes. I just paste them in.
If that is not true, put up any false quote I have ever made.
You are being dishonest Steve.
When I did quote that Guardian paragraph I quoted it in full, with a link.
I later just referred back to it.

"last week I looked at one and found that you were trying to mislead us"
One??
Jim Carroll


No.
Not one.
Put one up if that is not true.

The appalling incompetence, contempt and arrogance of military leaders of the time however are a matter of historical record.

It should be very easy to quote one of the historians agreeing that then.
Why can't you?

Maybe not Al, but one of these days somebody (no names, no pack-drill) is going to have to take a long, hard look at his public image

All those people caught lying I suppose.