This is very depressing. Keith is desperately clinging on to some technicality of his own invention. He is ignoring the immorality of what Israel is doing. Which, Keith, is to make life impossible for Palestinians in the areas in which they live but which Israel desires for itself, so that they will be forced out. They will be forced out of the Israel that the Israeli regime aspires to. Keith, you seriously need to address the moral issues here instead of clinging to your ridiculous "from Israel" nonsense. Israel does what it thinks will be accepted in the eyes of the west. If Israel thought it could get away with dumping every Arab on its soil.outside its border, it would. We know it would and you know it would. Kicking Palestinians out of areas Israel wants for settlements, and kicking Bedouins out of the Negev by destroying the villages in which they live, is ethnic cleansing. Ethnic cleansing of Palestinians out of the Israel that Israel wants. Focus on the morality issues, Keith, and leave your technicalities at the door. .