Windows XP Explorer: click View | Choose Details, then check Date Created. Clicking on the "Date Created" column should then show the files in creation order.

Windows 7 & 8: dunno. Probably something similar.

Windows 10: right-click anywhere in the column headings. Check "Date created", then click on that column heading.

And if all else fails, name your files with serially numbered prefixes... (been there, done that).