GUEST - 26 Nov 15 - 06:54 AM in what way does Ferguson support either "your" dogma or good ol' Jom's? Does he cast light on roaming bands of special groups of Redtops gunning down British soldiers who aren't moving at the desired rate? Does he argue that even although British casualty rates were lower than any other combatant powers on the western front that Britain's Generals were the poorest leaders, or that British forces were the worst led? By the way what exactly is "your" dogma? After all you've never told us what you think, and why you think it.

GUEST - 26 Nov 15 - 07:14 AM in what way does Dominic Alexander support either "your" dogma or good ol' Jom's? Does he cast light on roaming bands of special groups of Redtops gunning down British soldiers who aren't moving at the desired rate? Does he argue that even although British casualty rates were lower than any other combatant powers on the western front that Britain's Generals were the poorest leaders, or that British forces were the worst led? By the way what exactly is "your" dogma? After all you've never told us what you think, and why you think it.

As none of these questions will be answered all we have is just more GUEST "white noise" which it would appear that Keith A is silencing quicker that nameless GUEST can come up with suggestions. Now why is Jom not coming up with suggestions of his own - ah of course Jom's sources are drama and comedy scriptwriters and an ex-wife of Jom's most holy of holy's - Ewan MacColl "blessings be upon his name" - standing by for next incoherent rant interspersed with totally unwarranted, negative aspersions and contempt for those usefully employed in kitchens and galleys throughout the land and on the high seas. Strange really I thought that Jom always fancied himself as a champion of the working man, mind you he hasn't sunk so low down the scale as to call them "plebs" yet.