The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #158897   Message #3761806
Posted By: MGM·Lion
30-Dec-15 - 05:05 PM
Thread Name: a folk song with lots of incarnations
Subject: RE: a folk song with lots of incarnations
Sumer Is Icumen In is not 'traditional' at all, although anonymous. It is a composed work, known from manuscript in only one version, and not recorded in any oral traditional context; which surely precludes its being regarded as traditional in any sense which would satisfy a folklorist. It is not ∴ a folksong, & lacks any multiplicity of 'incarnations': both factors specifically demanded by the thread title.

≈M≈