Missed a bit
Re "New evidence"
WHAT NEW EVIDENCE? THERE IS NO NEW EVIDENCE AND EVEN IF THERE WAS, NO HISTORIAN HAS EVER AT ANY TIME WRITTEN OFF THE WORK OF PAST HISTORIANS - NOT EVER.
THEY MAY HAVE DISAGREED WITH WHAT HAS BEEN WRITTEN, BUT YOU HAVE WRITTEN EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM OFF IN ONE FELL SWOOP
Jim Carroll