Musket, the historians all say the army was well led.
Rag's book is especially positive about Haig.
What is your opinion worth against all of theirs?

Guest Dave,
Keith, they (historians) have been listed repeatedly and I am not going to repeat.

Completely untrue Dave.
You have found nothing written for at least twenty years that does not dismiss your beliefs as myths.

Andrew Adonis may not be an historian,.....

You can find a non-historian to say anything you want.
What you can not find is a single historian who believes that stuff you cling to in the defiance of every history book!