"Like the "eye witnesses" at Jenin, and the nurse "eye witnesses" on the MV Marmara who saw bodies thrown over the side. All liars."

That is as squalid and as desperate as it gets Keith - all the witnesses were liars
Ellen Siegal is an American Jewish nurse who was present at the massacre - she is a "liar" because her story doesn't corroborate the account given by the regime that has led to the present state of affairs in Israel that has not long perpetrated the massacre of 1,462 civilians - 344 children And 110 women
"You Redmond Report would not say that Israel was "directly responsible."
In your own words:
"The Redmond Enquiry found Israel guilty either "directly or indirectly" of the Sabra/Shatila massacre - guilty as that"
You have opted for "indirectly responsible" on the basis that all the witnesses were "liars"
Hope you never get to serve on jury duty in a British court Keith
Sickening!
It is only the lying enemies of Israel who say it is guilty of any massacres.
And that ends the official announcement from the Israeli terrorist regime

"No, Jim, you do not know.... but I am not surprised that he is your hero."
Then perhaps you might enlighten me Lilo - or is this to be yet another of your hit-and-run visits?
Jim Carroll

"ELLEN SIEGEL: I think what should happen to him is what has happened in our history, in Jewish history. Ever since I was a child, I have learned that what happened during the Holocaust happened because people were silent, people did not speak up. People allowed bad things to happen to other people and did not do anything about it. We should be the last people on Earth that should allow that to happen. Simon Wiesenthal continues and the Jewish agencies continue to look for Nazi war criminals, and indeed they should, and bring them to justice. Ariel Sharon is a war criminal. And the legal aspects of this, I understand, as a non-legal person, put him in that category. He allowed innocent people to be murdered. He did nothing to protect it. He knew that they were the sworn enemy of the Palestinians. And so, he should be tried."

"AMY GOODMAN: That was Ellen Siegel, the nurse who worked in the Sabra camp at the time of the massacre in 1982. Professor Rashid Khalidi, also with us, your relative headed that hospital called Gaza Hospital?AMY GOODMAN: That was Ellen Siegel, the nurse who worked in the Sabra camp at the time of the massacre in 1982. Professor Rashid Khalidi, also with us, your relative headed that hospital called Gaza Hospital?"
Chomsky