For crying out loud Keith Nurse Seigal was there for the duration of the massacre; far from seeing only "a small heap of bodies" she and her fellow medical staff treated them as they were brought in, talked to them, viewed the events from the top of the hospital (illuminated by Israeli flares throughout the three nights), were herded through the streets through the piles of bodies by the killers, expecting to meet with the fate of the victims (included in her testimony), witnssed the bulldozers brought in to dig the mass graves and finally, corresponded with an Israeli soldier she had seen from the top of the hospital.
Her experiences were thought important enough for her to have been interviewed by the Kahan Whitewash Committee.
What kind of a creature are you to go to such lengths to distort the account of an eye-witness in order to defend this massacre?
You included Nurse Seigal in your list of "liars" - whatever happened in Jenin has nothing to do with this massacre.
ONCE AGAIN YOU HAVE TAKEN IT ON YOURSELF TO DENY WHAT NOBODY ELSE HAS EVER DONE - WHO ELSE HAS EVER CALLED NURSE SEIGAL A LIAR?
"It is a tractic you should at least be aware of instead of swallowing every story without question."
During the recent Gaza massacres an Israeli spokesman claimed that the Israelis killed 1,000 terrorists - that has never been repeated - it was a lie - politicians and military men lie to further their cause.
You supported the "Friends of Israel" farrago of a report - you swallow it hook, line and sinker, without question; since it has been exposed as the shambles that it was, you have remained silent on it - ....you should at least be aware of instead of swallowing every story without question.
"No. It is Israel's side of the story."
Exactly - it was the defence of a regime that is fighting desperately to avoid being brought to book for war crimes and atrocities.
In the past they have relied on the U.S. to keep them from bing tried - after Gaza, Obama has told them they could not rely on America's support (one of your "respectable democracies")
"Redmond did not show them to have been "directly responsible" leaving it open."
Redmond did not "leave it open" - he said they were guilty of one or the other - since the events it has been shown they were possibly guilty of both - ye witnesses (whoops "liars") have placed them actually at the scene.
One woman described how she appealed to an Israeli soldier as she was being dragged away to be raped - he turned his back on her.
These people behaved like savages and you with all your Lord Haw-Haw enthusiasm, defend that savagery.
Jim Carroll