"I do not call Nurse Siegel a liar."
Having been given her statement -= you imply she is.
"She saw no-one massacred or buried."
No-one actually say the massacre - she and her colleagues heard it and she treated victims who told than what was going on.
On the basis of eye witness accounts from both victims and Israeli soldiers who were there, the Redmond enquiry found Israel "either "directly or indirectly" of the Sabra/Shatila massacre"
"Ne evidence of a massacre. There had been Ne evidence of a massacre. There had been fighting in the camp
WHAT!!!!
You are now implying that there was no massacere but the deaths were due to "Ne evidence of a massacre. There had been fighting in the camp"
What are you on Keith?
"It leaves it open as directly or indirectly responsible."
Redmond does not leave guilt open - he says they were guilty of either one or the other
You are deliberately twisting
You are lying about this - you have never read the "Redmond Report" - have you
Jim Carroll