WorldCat.org shows that the Toledo-Lucas County Public Library has a copy of the sheet music for THE NIGHT MALONEY LANDED IN NEW YORK, words and music by J. D. Flynn, published by J. D. Flynn in Long Island City, NY, ©1899. (Alas, it's not viewable online.)

The catalog entry says it has 4 verses. That suggests that the lyrics posted by our Guest on 04 Oct 2010 should be grouped as four 12-line stanzas. The fact that every 12th line is "On the night Maloney landed in New York" confirms this.