The Pettit version I posted was from Hilliard Smith of Kentucky and a MS version was given to Campbell in 1910. In 1917 Sharp collected the same version (his C). Smith sang the ballad two ways- with two endings (see Sharp MS).
The Coon Creek Girls formed in the mid- 1930s in Renfro Valley (as a radio group) and were sisters Lily May and Rosie Ledford (from Powell County, Kentucky) along with Esther "Violet" Koehler (from Indiana) and Evelyn "Daisey" Lange (from Ohio).
After listening to both I have a correction:
"Gold, diamonds on her fingers and her lily white hands"