The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #159731   Message #3785504
Posted By: Jack Campin
15-Apr-16 - 02:41 PM
Thread Name: Stushie to Heaven
Subject: Stushie to Heaven
Dispute over plagiarism in Stairway to Heaven:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-27497950

However. I got this from my friend Sam Waylen yesterday, he was going to send it to the press:

I note with mischievous glee the legal dispute taking place between these two bands.

With glee because I believe that the fact is, the arpeggiated chord sequence in question pre-dates BOTH bands.

Veteran Jazz fans may remember that in the late Fifties, there was a version of the spiritual "Motherless Child" in which the backing guitarist  featured this four chord sequence behind the vocals, which Spirit themselves may be said to have, at least unwittingly, borrowed the idea from.

I doubt whether "Jazzers" have been following this argument between a Heavy Metal band and a Psychedelic Rock band, but I would reckon that if you offered this information to them, there would be a fair few who, after giving either recording the most cursory appraisal could place the identity of the guitarist, the singer, and too, more essentially, for legal purposes the date of, what I am asserting, may well be the first recording of these chords in the non-Classical genre.


Anyone know what version of "Motherless Child" he remembers? Obviously not Louis Armstrong's.