Before I shut up on the matter and leave it to those who know something about it, here is the two-verse version that turned up online in the wikiverse forums, which corresponds most closely to what Maire Ni Scolai recorded for HMV years before I was even born.
EIBHLÍN A RÚIN
lyrics attributed to Carroll O'Daly melody as recorded by Maire Ni Scolai for HMV
Má chaith mé mo bhróga leat a Eibhlín a rúin Má chaith mé mo bhróga leat a Eibhlín a rúin Má chaith mé mo bhróga leat Má ghearr síos na scorthaí leat Mar shúil is go mbeinn pósta leat a Eibhlín a rúin
An dtiocfaidh tú nó an bhfanfaidh tú a Eibhlín a rúin An dtiocfaidh tú nó an bhfanfaidh tú a Eibhlín a rúin Tiocfaidh mé 's ní fhanfaidh mé Bí romham is leanfad tú A ghrá le mo chroí faoi rún is tú a Eibhlín a rúin