The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #159827   Message #3793965
Posted By: Keith A of Hertford
05-Jun-16 - 01:33 PM
Thread Name: BS: (UK) Whither the Labour Party
Subject: RE: BS: (UK) Whither the Labour Party
"Jim, I have never claimed anything about Chakarbarti."]You put her up to suggest that she supported your case - she doesn't - you aer now back-pedaling - it's what you do.

Not true.
Her name just appeared incidentally in a quote I pasted in.
I had never typed her name before you made that false claim.

"He did accuse Corbyn of failing to call out Labour antisemitism."
That is a political criticism of how Corbyn acted, not a suggestion of any problem


No. It shows that he knows of antisemitism that Corbyn has done nothing about.

any Labour person who supports Israel is supporting an extremist terrorist State.

No liberal democracy or democratic party regards Israel as such.
Your assertion is based on nothing, and is false.

You have been given the Guardian comments - you ignore them

Yes, as you ignore the Guardian comments that say the opposite.

How dare you - where have I?

You appear to believe that we should dismiss the views on antisemitism of anyone who supports Israel.

You are the ones who link the Jewish people as a whole to Israeli war crimes, massacres and acts of terror - not me.

Like every liberal democracy in the world, I do not accept that Israel has committed any "war crimes, massacres and acts of terror."

I am not so gullible as to accept without question the propaganda of Israel's enemies.