Keith, I understand fully how you need LabourList by your side as a commentary on all that's wrong with Labour (they don't pull their punches, do they, so quite handy for you), but it is most decidedly NOT a house journal. It is a bunch of people who purport to be broadly centre-left who support the concept of a centre-left party in power (there is only one possibility, of course). As for "it provides that role and there is no other," that logic is laughable. Who says there has to be one? As for my not knowing it wasn't Labour, well as I receive the daily newsletter that would be rather odd. 😂😂😂 Anyway, the point is that it is is not as close to Labour as you want it to be, and using it in any way as a Labour mouthpiece is simply out of order. As for liars around here, there are only two, and you are both of 'em. 😅