The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #159827   Message #3804307
Posted By: Jim Carroll
09-Aug-16 - 10:27 AM
Thread Name: BS: (UK) Whither the Labour Party
Subject: RE: BS: (UK) Whither the Labour Party
Bit surprised you have the nerve to show your face again here after your having been exposed as a hypocrite and an apologist for Antisemitism
You want to prove there's a problem with Antisemitism in the Labour party, tell us what it is, who's involved and how many.
The idea of putting a Party with no history of antisemitism or bigotry on trial and refusing to specify what those charges are and who you are accusing is bloody obscene.
Even Stalin wenbt to the trouble of trumping up charges and providing some sort of evidence
You are a pair of extremist half-wits - and you are an apologist for antisemitism, so your reasons for behaving the way you do is to push your ow nextremist agenda
who are these antisemites - what have they said that makes them antisemitic - how many of them are there?   
Answer that you you may hAve a CASE - THIS IS GETTING BLOODY RIDICULOUS - A TRAIL WITHOUT SPECIFYING THE CHARGES AND REFUSING TO NAME THE ACCUSED - WHAT EXTREMIST WORLD DO YOU LIVE IN?
"Chakrabarti's Report ensures the latter."
No it doesn't until some solid evidence proves there to be a problem with Antisemitism in the Labour Party the verdict of the survey stands
You have produced no evidence, neither has anybody else.
"Charmingly put as ever Jom."
Don't thik you have any grounds for complaint about how to address people =- you are an ill-mannered thug - I took my cue from you.
"Does support for Hamas count as legitimate protest against the Israeli Government?"
Support for the Palestinian People does not count - unfortunately, as things Stand in the Middle East, Hamas is the only opposition the Palestinians have against Israeli terrorism so, no, of course it does not count.
Ironically, Hamas has not acted in any way different from all resistance movements involved in National Liberation - including the Jewish Freedom Fighters who fought for the State of Israel.
Israel is carrying out a war of ethnic cleansing to create a monotheist State - what rules of warfare do you suggest the Palestinians adopt to stop that from happening.
And no - I am not a Hamas supporter, but I see the peresent alternative to them unthinkable as things stand
Had the U.S. not protected Israel with their vetoes, Israel would have stood trial for atrocities long ago.
"Does singing "Rockets over Tel Aviv" count"
(Won't take advantage of the amusing typo - as you would)
No more than using chemical or anti-personnel weapons, or facilitation the massacre of 3,500 unarmed refugees..... or all the other atrocities carried out against a civilian and largely unarmed Third World people "counts" - but shit happens in war.
Show thaty these things never happened and you might have a case - I suppose you could take Keith's line and just deny them
Aren't you one of the people who claimed that the Arabs have no right to Palestine - cae proven, I think - another supporter of the Israeli regime taking a pop at Labour - a pattern well established, I think
Jim Carroll