Hi Richie,
Thank you so much for this comprehensive list of versions! I note that at the end of the 1958 recording, Lizzie is asked who she learned it from, and she says the name and that it was 12 years before, so in 1946, when she would have been only about 17 years old, but I'm afraid I can't quite make it out. I am pretty sure the last name is Mcallister, but not sure of the first one. You will probably be able to make it out.
Heather