The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #160410   Message #3825791
Posted By: Jim Carroll
11-Dec-16 - 09:58 AM
Thread Name: BS: Labour party discussion
Subject: RE: BS: Labour party discussion
"The Bedouin "villages" were temporary encampments as they were a nomadic people."
It doesn't matter - it has nothing to do with the Israeli regime, and even if it had, a toxic rubbish dump is no alternative settlement
"The encampments were on untitled land"
They were there before Israel became Israel
"When Israel became a state all untitled land became property of the state"
No it did not, any more than houses occupied by Arabs did - there were people living there and by "squatters rights" the land was theirs.
I take it by your silence that you have no argument with the toxic site and the use of chemicals and water cannon to evict them (or is that more "Carroll made-up shit"
Are you really defending this obscene behavior?
Please say "yes"
Jim Carroll