Totally embarrassing memories of records I wore out:

Shelley Fabares, "Johnny Angel"
The Caravelles (I think) "You Don't Have To Be A Baby To Cry"
"Wolverton Mountain" (we have had a great thread on Wolverton Mountain)
One of those cheap albums of covers of hit songs that I can only remember from the cover versions -- songs like "Why?" ("I think you're awfully sweet, Why because I love you, etc., etc." Yuccccckkkk).

yours, Peter T.