Steve,
Well this discussion about Wheatcroft has been about the "not an historian" thread, which, like other threads, stands alone as a discrete area of discussion.

No. It is about the Wheatcroft discussion which took place on two threads simultaneously with the same participants including you.

I introduced the article into the discussion because it wholly supported my case, and I quoted the relevant passage in full.

Your case against me has failed.
You lose.

Now, can you challenge anything I have posted in this thread this year?