Dave,
The Labour party is no more antosemitic than any other

That is your opinion, but many promininent members have said that it is. There have been no complaints from Jews in other parties.

I said that Shah was a prat (note not just a prat) but you did not believe that.

I think that making racist comments is worse than being a prat.
You did not say she was anything but a prat, so just a prat to you.

What you refuse to say is if you believe as Jim and Steve do that her remarks were not anti-Semitic and she did not advocate the transportation even though she freely admits she did.

Will you now?
Why not?
Nothing circular or repeated. Entirely new.