Dave, I am not asking you to discuss anything.
Just to clarify your views on Shah.

Do you agree with Steve and Jim that her comments were not ant-Semitic and she did not advocate transportation even though she freely admits both, or with me that she did.

I doubt that you are concerned about hurting my feelings by disagreeing with me.
I am sure you do agree with me but are concerned about your friends' feelings.
They are grown men Dave.
They know that even friends can not agree on everything.

Steve,
Very, very clear indeed, Keith. Dave says that the Labour Party is no more antisemitic than any other.
That is your opinion, but many promininent members have said that it is.

Yes. They have said that Labour has a serious problem with it, not other parties.
Labour Jews have complained about the Party's anti-Semitism but none from other parties have.