The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #163473   Message #3901234
Posted By: Jack Campin
23-Jan-18 - 08:16 AM
Thread Name: The impossibility of describing music
Subject: RE: The impossibility of describing music
Some writers have done very well at describing their own or their characters' responses to music, putting the music itself in the background. Three that come to mind:

- Kerouac describing his response to George Shearing in "On the Road"

- Carson McCullers describing her character's response to the Eroica in "The Heart is a Lonely Hunter"

- Halldor Laxness describing listening to Roberto Gerhard's violin concerto in "The Atom Station".

These are all brilliant writing by any standard.

Thomas Mann does a virtuoso performance of describing a piece which is sort of based on Schoenberg's "Die Jacobsleiter" in "Doctor Faustus". In a way he makes it easy for himself by describing something imaginary, but he does get the effect of a piece using massive-scale formal mirrored structure right.