The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #164041   Message #3922436
Posted By: beardedbruce
05-May-18 - 11:05 PM
Thread Name: BS: Israel's Sharpville
Subject: RE: BS: Israel's Sharpville
"You have accused me again and now you have the evidence that I have not lied in front of you"

No evidence that I see of what you claim. Just an arguement that YOU have not won, just made claims about. According to YOUR logic, the statements by the Palestinian leadership of of no value in determining what THEY believe- so how can songs by Facists possibly show what Keith or others here believe?

"You have accused me of lying several times yet have yet to come up with a single example "

I have, repeatedly- and am waiting on that donation. YOU may not have agreed- but then, YOU make statements all the time about what others believe and say that are YOUR opinion, and expect us to treat it as fact- So you may do the same for me, and consider it proven, if that will make you happy. Otherwise, admit you have been wrong in many of tyour statements of opinion, or at least provide some discussion beyond your declaration that it is factual.



"So you accuse half the population of demanding a crime against humanity and the Israeli Government of responding to that demand"

NO- I accuse 83% of the Palestinians of demanding a crime against humanity, and YOU supporting them in that crime.



"I have never at any time supported any call for ethnic cleansing (show where I have)"

OH?? When you call for the West Bank to be given to the Palestinians as a state ( and you have called for more than that!) when the vast majority ( posted in other threads- 83% of the Palestinians?) do NOT permit Jews to be allowed to settle in the Palestinian State ( as the were/are NOT allowed to settle in the 77% of Mandate Palestine that formed the ARAB PALESTINAN state of TransJordan in 1923).



"Israel is blaming the Jews for what they are doing and many are taking their word for it."

No.IMO, from your posts, YOU are the one blaming Israel, and not the specific individuals YOU claim are doing these things.

"- what I have said is that the Israeli regime's Implicating the Jewish People in their crimes by hiding behind the accusation of "antisemitism" to excuse them is the cause of the sharp rise in antisemitism in the world today - Israel is blaming the Jews for what they are doing and many are taking their word for it."

YES- YOU have said this. IMO, it is unsupported by the facts. YOU are lying or stating your opinion- which UNPROVEN is enough to label YOU as Anti-semitic.


"I expect a reply to this one"

You have a reply- but I doubt if you will agree to anything. You never do, unless you have twisted it to where no-one would recognize it compared to the original post.


You may not like my reply- but it is one- and MY opinion is as valid ( and more so, when the facts I have previously posted are recalled) as yours.