"What worries me most in this thread is that all contributors except for "GUEST,Gerry 07 Dec 18 - 07:05 AM" are absolutely sure they know who is a villain."

Please don't make such a sweeping statement without evidence to back it up.

Have you really read every post in this thread carefully, and then fairly concluded that 'all contributors ... are absolutely sure they know who is a villain'? My guess is 'no'!