The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #165445 Message #3968961
Posted By: Pamela R
31-Dec-18 - 12:33 AM
Thread Name: traditional songs - best for learning?
Subject: RE: traditional songs - best for learning?
Finding a regional version is a nice idea if you live somewhere for which such could be found.
I agree with several others above regarding the benefits of learning the songs, if not in person, at least from recordings (rather than from print); so I will annotate my suggestions above with some audio sources:
False Lover John - for example Corney McDaid's version or Fred Jordan's "Six Pretty Maids"
Willie O' the Windsbury - I am partial to Anne Briggs' version, omitting the guitar, perhaps only because I learned that one first. I suppose this song may fall into the overdone category; but some versions are so different as to be entirely fresh (e.g.,"There was a lady lived in the west" by Robert Cinnamond, on VOTP17).
Jock O' Hazeldean - Dick Gaughan's version is gorgeous.
Well Sold the Cow/The Crafty Farmer - I love both Bess Cronin's and Packie Byrne's versions.
Feein' Day/Hiring Day - Ellen Mitchell's very charming version or Michael Gallagher's