well in that case its worked. His post has got more attention than most of the stuff I post on mudcat.

Theres like a scintilla of sense in there. We DONT recognise relationships of songs that stare us in the face. And are the bare bones of folksong.

However its the snotty putdown of people who do their best that hints that he might not be the sort of person you'd give a shit about what they'd think, that undermines the article.