I have responded to this and all of your questions

I must have missed that then. Where did I say that anything should go at folk clubs and what makes you think that people on here sing songs with 'no identity'?

As to answering you questions, I pointed out on the referenced post that "Some time ago I put up a list of things I believe make folk song unique, yo ignored it - I asked again", is not a question, it is a statement. I have no idea how to answer it. Let me know what question comes out of that and I will gladly comply.

I think you are confused as to who said what and which arguments you are having with whom