Tucker: "FIFER AND FIDLER. Two very important aids in eliciting exact discipline; for hoisting, warping, and heaving at the capstan in proper time..."

Gibb: "On the other other hand, if singing chanties was not part of the discipline of being in the military on land, then why expect it in the military environment on the sea?"

Sailors & Marines: The fife, drum, trumpet, march or cadence serves on land as it does on deck. In light boats, landing parties &c the distinction is academic. The infantry fiddle concept however...