I don't think anyone does, Jim, but I think you are being unnecessarily wary of online communications. There is nothing passive about this forum for instance. There is no reason why the internet cannot be used to share talents and live performances much like folk clubs do. The issue could be keeping the number of participants to a manageable level! As well as a channel to share live performances it could also contain a chat box for personal conversations and a 'panel' to give constructive advice. If it was set up correctly the moderators could veto cover versions of Buddy Holly to their hearts content :-)

Correct me if I am wrong but I am sure you once said that Ewan welcomed new technology. Imagine what could have been done with the critics group given the worldwide nature of such an online forum.

Don't get me wrong here. I am not advocating that online clubs should replace live venues. But as an enhancement and as a way of getting more people involved, I cannot envisage a better way forward.