The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #140761 Message #4066417
Posted By: Acorn4
29-Jul-20 - 10:09 AM
Thread Name: Are racist, but traditional, songs OK?
Subject: RE: Tech: Hints for Zoom Singaround Hosts
It's a very thorny problem and can extend to areas like songs about whaling and hunting.
Can you disapprove of both and still sing the songs, as a lot of them are cracking songs.
In essence when you sing a folk song you are, in a sense, acting. In a play you could be acting the part of a Shakespearian villain, which bears no relation to your own beliefs or behaviour.
If you are an atheist you might be offended by religious references. We have a person who attends our local sessions who tuts at the end of a song with any religious connotations.
I've tried telling him "you don't have to be a psychopath to sing a murder ballad" to no avail.
We'd need to ban the whole of Kipling if you read the use of the "n" word in the "Just So" stories.
Not coming to any conclusions here but just a few thoughts and just saying that the implications are far reaching.