The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #82980 Message #4100837
Posted By: Steve Gardham
05-Apr-21 - 08:41 AM
Thread Name: Origins: Elfin Knight (Child #2)
Subject: RE: Origins: Elfin Knight (Child #2)
Hi Joe, firstly, what has The Devil's Courtship got to do with The Elfin Knight? TDC is a version of The Paper of Pins/ the Keys of Canterbury/Heaven, Roud 573.
Secondly, Robert is not quite correct about 'Acre of Land'. It has its own autonomy and should rightly be classified as a separate song to Elfin Knight, BUT it is clearly derived from Elfin Knight and the evolution from one song to the other can be clearly traced.
Quite a few of what Bronson calls 'secondary versions' of Child Ballads are not even related to the ballad, but in this case 'Acre of Land' must be conceived as a secondary form of 'Elfin Knight'